Jump to content






Photo - - - - -

I hate Windows and prefer my Mac. Simple.

Posted by Rikki, 07 December 2005 · 70 views

Let's start with the positive, shall we?

I ordered a cinema display this week. I got the 20" one - I'd have loved the 23" but it was just too expensive pinch.gif It's actually my christmas present but I'm paying some towards it too. One word: fantastic. Whether it's better than other monitors of a similar spec I don't know, but as someone going from a 17" samsung TFT to a 20" Apple TFT I'm blown away. The widescreen just makes such a difference to your computer habits. The bigger res is nice too. Watching a DVD up close isn't a spectacular affair, but then DVD's aren't a high enough res to expect it anyway. From a distance it'd be fine. HD video on the other hand is outstanding. Again, the widescreen means you can see everything so much bigger, even though technically the monitor is only 3" bigger. On the side of the monitor are 3 iPod-style touch sensitive buttons for brightness and on/off. You can set the on/off button to put the computer to sleep which is a nice feature. It has 2 firewire and 2 USB ports tucked neatly away on the back which is also handy. As expected the build quality is superb. A worthy purchase if I may say so.

OK, positive out the way. Onto the negative.

Unsurprisingly, Windows is to blame. What a pain in the ass it is, seriously. I'm stuck here trying to fix a damn laptop because Windows has cocked up just for a change. My brothers PC has all sorts of crap on it and it's spreading across the network (of course, not to my Macs though...). I don't know if that's got anything to do with it, but my parents switched on their laptop today and "WININET.DLL could not be found" comes up. It goes to the desktop then does sod all. I managed to download a copy of the dll from the net and copy it over. Now windows starts but won't bring up any Windows windows, like control panel, IE, or Windows Explorer. Great. The whole architecture of Windows is rubbish. I'm pissed off that I have to use my time dealing with fixing Windows because of it's inabilities as an OS. Why should anyone have to spend their time messing around with virus scanners, adware cleaners, bugs, flaws, holes? Having to deal with those left my mind when I switched to Mac 2 years ago. Yes, I'm bitter I'm now having to clean up a Windows mess again.




Wow.  Great entry, as I agree with everything you said about Windows and Mac in there.  Since I have the 20" iMac G5 w/ iSight, I love the display, but it's the same as a cinema display.  I was at the Apple Store and I was looking at the 30" cinema display, and that was absolutely gorgeous. wub.gif  I think Mac is simply the best type of computer ever made as Mac's have a closed architecture, meaning it is virtually impossible for a virus to infect the Mac as it is UNIX format and no one ever writes for UNIX viruses anymore as it's just simply too hard, time-consuming, and confusing.  Also, Mac's are guaranteed to never freeze like Windows does, ugh, that's what I HATE Windows the most for (besides the "Blue Screen of Death")! getlost.gif



Mac > Windows thumbsup.gif  

QUOTE(Brandon C @ Dec 7 2005, 08:40 PM)

Also, Mac's are guaranteed to never freeze like Windows does, ugh, that's what I HATE Windows the most for (besides the "Blue Screen of Death")! getlost.gif


Mac's do freeze - just not as frequently.
QUOTE(Brandon C @ Dec 8 2005, 01:40 AM)

Wow.  Great entry, as I agree with everything you said about Windows and Mac in there.  Since I have the 20" iMac G5 w/ iSight, I love the display, but it's the same as a cinema display.  I was at the Apple Store and I was looking at the 30" cinema display, and that was absolutely gorgeous. wub.gif  I think Mac is simply the best type of computer ever made as Mac's have a closed architecture, meaning it is virtually impossible for a virus to infect the Mac as it is UNIX format and no one ever writes for UNIX viruses anymore as it's just simply too hard, time-consuming, and confusing.  Also, Mac's are guaranteed to never freeze like Windows does, ugh, that's what I HATE Windows the most for (besides the "Blue Screen of Death")! getlost.gif



Mac > Windows thumbsup.gif


I think you're a bit disillusioned wink.gif Macs can crash too, but they rarely do. OS X can 'bomb' where the screen goes grey with a bomb in the middle - I've never had it happen to me, but it can happen. Program crashes happen fairly frequently for me, but that's fine, as long as it doesn't take down everything else with it. XP is better than older versions in that respect, but it can still cause issues. For example, the problem I posted about. A system file just randomly being deleted by a program. That'd be very difficult to do on a mac because any system level changes require a password, period. That's another reason why virii are difficult - but not impossible - to write for Mac. Anything potentially damaging needs authorization by the user.

Mac is stable, but it's not invincible like you assume.
All I can say is... I dream of owning a Mac!!!  sad.gif
When I win the lottery Ken, there's a Mac coming your way thumbsup.gif
My mac has crashed on my once. However it was nicer than a windows crash. It actually told me it had crashed and turned off my Mac for me tongue.gif Nicer than the windows blue screen of death tongue.gif

Anyways I am really loving the 20" on my iMac. But since my iMac is now in my dads office I am having to use my 12" iBook more. It kind of hard going from 20" -> 12" sad.gif

Anyway before I get a cinema display I am going to wait for them to update them, since they are getting a bit behind the times spec wise.
QUOTE(Starnox @ Dec 8 2005, 10:03 PM)
My mac has crashed on my once. However it was nicer than a windows crash. It actually told me it had crashed and turned off my Mac for me tongue.gif Nicer than the windows blue screen of death tongue.gif

Anyways I am really loving the 20" on my iMac. But since my iMac is now in my dads office I am having to use my 12" iBook more. It kind of hard going from 20" -> 12" sad.gif

Anyway before I get a cinema display I am going to wait for them to update them, since they are getting a bit behind the times spec wise.


Windows can be configured to not show BSODs and instead just reboot and inform you there was a crash. tongue.gif
Funny, I haven't had a BSOD or crash in the past 5 years (ever since I have been running XP Pro)

XP Home for some reason doesn't seem to have the same reliability, I have a family member that uses Home and it will go down every once in a while.
I have had a few BSODs with XP Pro, it does hang up a lot more than my mac does though... and i do prefer mac to windows. But i'm not an anti-windows person, it has it's good points as well... (can't think what they are at the moment though! tongue.gif )  I'd love a powermac or an imac, i only have a 12" powerbook at the moment. original.gif
QUOTE(• Jay • @ Dec 10 2005, 05:47 AM)

Funny, I haven't had a BSOD or crash in the past 5 years (ever since I have been running XP Pro)

I haven't had a BSOD since changing to XP Pro either. I sometimes have the "Ending Program" thing come up when I shut the computer down, but I do use it pretty extremely. I have tonnes of programs and have Windowblinds + Konfabulator + Object Dock running all the time.

I really like OSX and Windows. I don't see the point in complaining about either. At work we use Macs for audio and video editing. You can get a Mac to crash often with that kind of use, but they're still better than Windows for that type of work.
I'm not sure if it's just the direction the comments have taken or if it's a misconception about my post, but I just want to make it clear: I haven't seen a BSOD on XP yet. The problem I had was to do with a system file being removed by what I expect was a virus (or other application). That just shouldn't be acceptable. Additionally I'm annoyed that Windows users (or system maintainers (me)) have to spend time and money fortifying their computer (beyond a firewall which I accept is necessary on any machine) just because Windows has an insecure design that allows any program to do anything. I don't have to spend time or money doing it on Mac, why should I have to on Windows? If it were designed properly the need to do so would be far reduced.
QUOTE(Starnox @ Dec 8 2005, 10:03 PM)

My mac has crashed on my once. However it was nicer than a windows crash. It actually told me it had crashed and turned off my Mac for me tongue.gif Nicer than the windows blue screen of death tongue.gif


QUOTE(Den Watts @ Dec 9 2005, 07:00 PM)

Windows can be configured to not show BSODs and instead just reboot and inform you there was a crash. tongue.gif


It has done that by default since XP was released

QUOTE(Rikki @ Dec 10 2005, 03:53 PM)
If it were designed properly the need to do so would be far reduced.


Hindsight is a wonderful thing wink.gif When Windows was originally created security wasn't a major concern in the computing industry. The same thing is true of TCP/IP, which are inheritly insecure and like Windows is the most widely used in its field (there are alternatives to TCP/IP); yet people don't whine and moan about that because they don't know about it.

It's all well and good saying Microsoft should change the way Windows works to make it more secure but  changing the architecture of Windows is not as simple as some people make it sound, normally because of the very people who are 'Barneys Girlfriend'ing wink.gif They 'Barneys Girlfriend' that Microsoft don't change the way Windows works, but if they do change the way things work to make it more secure they then 'Barneys Girlfriend' when old applications no longer work. Apple were able to make the major changes between OS 9 and OS X because of the relatively small and relatively more computer literate (note to Mac users don't get a big head thinking Mac users are smarter than their PC using counterparts) user base. Microsoft doesn't have that luxury so it takes time and has to be staggered across releases.
Hindsight is wonderful, but the fact it was designed before it mattered isn't a good excuse. If the wheels fell off a car when you drove on certain roads, you'd expect them to fix it pronto even if those roads were built after the car. Apple did make the change, and applications did have to be completely rewritten for the new OS, but they included 'Classic' so that old applications would still run, a good compromise I think.

I remember reading that Microsofts plan was to do the same for Vista and require that all applications be modified to work on it. I guess they backed down after a while which is a shame. In the short term it would be annoying, obviously, but it would help so much in the long term.
The move to XP-64 explains the situation. A couple of programs don't run on it and need to be rewritten, but the userbase just isn't big enoug yet for software developers to do this rappidly. So in the end users are waiting for their software to be upgraded to 64bit and software developers are waiting for enough users using XP 64bit.  So if Vista is gonna require a lot of software to be rewritten; I think Vista will not become popular very fast... eventually it'll get there tho.
Yeah, I know what you mean. When I loaded Windows on my computer, it came equipt with 47 errors. I would switch and probably will switch over to Mac when I go to colledge, but for now I'll deal with Windows. Macs are just kind of expensive and oddly shaped in my opinion. The Mac graphics are amazing though; probably the best I've seen. Also Linux OS' are pretty nice. I actually am quite a fan of Fedora and Xandros. Linux may even be better than Mac if it had more software readily available.
QUOTE(Brandon C @ Dec 8 2005, 01:40 AM)

Also, Mac's are guaranteed to never freeze like Windows does, ugh, that's what I HATE Windows the most for (besides the "Blue Screen of Death")! getlost.gif


Hah!  Read on...

QUOTE(Starnox @ Dec 8 2005, 10:03 PM)

My mac has crashed on my once. However it was nicer than a windows crash. It actually told me it had crashed and turned off my Mac for me tongue.gif Nicer than the windows blue screen of death tongue.gif


My mac has:
  • Completely frozen with absolutely no information.
  • Crashed with the elegant "You need to restart your computer" screen.
  • Crashed to kernel debugger, which if you've seen in Linux is a terrifying sight, especially overlaying the OS X desktop.
  • After crashing during a system update, upon rebooting I was presented not with an eye-candy enriched GUI, but the Darwin login terminal. blink.gif

Don't get me wrong, these all happened after upgrading to Tiger. It would seem that Tiger does not like my Powerbook with 1 GB of RAM. Luckily a later update cured that problem as up til then I had to take out the 1GB stick and just use the stock 250MB one. pinch.gif

Now, it runs like a dream. Only the odd app crash now and again. Mainly Firefox and iTunes (and I know exactly what causes the crash, so I just avoid those conditions).

I agree fully with Rikki though. In terms of day to day upkeep, OS X is *BY FAR* better than Windows, and that, in part is due to the simplicity of the architecture.

May 2012

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20 21 2223242526
2728293031  

Recent Entries

XBox Live Gamercard

Disclaimer

Please note that none of my blogging is official IPS business. Opinions and other things I say are mine and not IPS'.

0 user(s) viewing

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users